Today’s lesson, boys and girls, is that children’s cartoons should not be childish cartoons. No matter how much goodwill your main characters cart around with them.
Challenge of the Superfriends comes from the 1970’s, the era which also gave us disco, which should be considered a warning. The Superfriends are actually the Justice League of America – in other words, a goodly selection of DC superheros. The head honcho is none other than Superman, but we also have Wonder Woman, Batman and Robin, the Flash and others. (Including Hawkman, whose super power is that he can fly. Amongst this crowd, big deal)
The Justice League is never actually called the Justice League here. No, they are always and forever called the Superfriends. I don’t think they could have given themselves a lamer title, but hold that thought.
Heroes require villains, and so we have the Legion of Doom. Which, for some reason, likes hiding literally in a swamp. It’s headed by Lex Luthor, who at least merits serious respect (The fact that a mere human can struggle for so long against Superman is extraordinary). The Legion is filled with insane powerful beings, a virtual platoon of super-geniuses, and a guy who owns a boat.
But this is a cartoon series of children. Who cares? Well, I’ve seen things like
The Incredibles. Unlike the creators of this mess, I’ve seen cartoons with good plots, credible dialogue, ingenious animation and well-done voice acting. In contrast, the motto of
Challenge of the Superfriends is ‘We don’t care.’
For example, they don’t care that the plots are insane. In the very first episode, the Legion of Doom uses a satellite to turn every man on Earth into a Bizzaro clone – imagine a cross between Superman and Kryten from
Red Dwarf - and to bring them all the money on Earth. Since only thirteen people on Earth will now have any money, it effectively becomes worthless.
In another episode, Toyman (whose special power is that he’s really irritating) builds an artificial planet in the middle of a black hole. Not just near a black hole, in the
centre of a black hole. Three of the Superfriends land on it. Yes, they survive
falling into a black hole.
I say again, it’s a BLACK HOLE!
And I haven’t yet said anything about the Legion’s plan to trap the Superfriends inside
Alice in Wonderland. When they create an army of unstoppable zombies it’s positively conventional.
The Legion is in desperate need of good corporate governance, because their plans are poorly thought-out with questionable objectives. An evil genius would want to take over the world, but taking over the world in a thousand years time, when it’s little more than a barren rock inhabited by mutants, is not such an illustrious goal. Neither has the Legion yet realised that turning yourself into a giant will not necessarily stop every army in Europe (honestly, when Toyman conquers Britain with a giant clockwork tank, I was so embarrassed for my nation). As for Africa, I doubt that a gorilla army (no projectile weapons, no transportation) would conquer even that under-funded continent.
Of course, if the plot does whatever the writers wish, the characters must all be morons. In one of my favourite episodes, Luthor creates a sun flare that accidentally ends up destroying all human life on Earth. Good going, Luthor. And the only reason why the Superfriends stop it is… well, actually they don’t. A group of aliens do it for them. Yes, that’s right. The only reason why supervillain incompetence fails to kill everyone is because a bunch of aliens do the Superfriends’ work for them. How inspiring.
Don’t think that the Superfriends do any better. The Legion of Doom tries out the ‘we’re good guys now’ routine. They promise to turn over a new leaf and start stopping crime and catching criminals. The Superfriends fall for it and as a consequence an entire alien civilisation, that was begging the Superfriends for help, gets destroyed. All praise to you, Superman!
You would have thought that, when you have a dozen superheros fighting a dozen supervillains, some deaths would result. I wouldn’t expect any of them to die – that would kill the DC cashcow – but there would be violence and collateral damage. The Legion of Doom would at least succeed in killing someone. Or injuring someone. Or, for God’s sake, giving someone a paper cut.
But no.
I’ve seen more violence committed against Noddy.
Oh, they have fights. If you can call them that. At the end of each and every episode there’s about thirty seconds of the two groups playing tag; once you’re touched lightly on the back by Batman, even if you have super-strength and can crack his head open like an egg in less than a second, you have to give in. That’s the rule.
This ‘no violence’ policy is strongly adhered to, even to the point where the massed armies of the world refuse to attack psychopaths. And this, of all things, is why they’re called the Superfriends; because children must be taught the value of friendship and that violence is wrong. Yes, I know that the bad guys are supposed to do ‘wrong things’ and they try to kill people and rob banks and the like, but you mustn’t show them hitting anyone. You can’t even allow them to use weapons that would actually kill anyone. The one exception to this is an episode in which the Legion of Doom thinks it’s killed the Superfriends, but it hasn’t really. It would have been much more interesting if it had.
The characters suck. I don’t often use the word ‘suck’, but here it expresses my contempt for these morons wonderfully. In fact the doubtful word is ‘characters’ as nobody exhibits a personality of any kind. The good guys are good, the bad guys are bad and that’s it. The only person to make any impression is Toyman, because he’s so completely annoying.
If I had to express a preference, it would be for the bad guys, because they are at least
doing something. A typical episode goes like this – the Legion of Doom come up with an Evil Plan and give a good old maniacal laugh. One of them, Sinestro, even has a thin moustache to twirl. The plan often includes making the Superfriends look like Supernitwits, which is not particularly difficult. Afterwards the Superfriends only leap into action once the Legion has made its move.
This means that when the Legion isn’t doing anything, the Superfriends sit around watching television and eating nachos, while Superman uses his x-ray vision to stare at Wonder Woman’s chest. The thought of being proactive and
getting off their backsides to catch the Legion before the Legion commits a crime doesn’t occur to them.
So the Legion gets the upper hand for most of the episode. But then they get overambitious or put the Superfriends in an easily escapable death trap, and the Superfriends win. The Superfriends then let the Legion escape for no other reason than laziness.
Still, we shouldn’t be too harsh. Clearly the Superfriends are not the sharpest knives in the kitchen. Whatever happens, no matter how obvious it is, they all feel compelled to narrate for themselves what’s happening. Imagine that the Riddler is robbing a jewellery shop, and Batman runs into him.
BATMAN: Great heavens! It’s the Riddler!
(He sees that the Riddler is at a jewellery shop)
BATMAN: He’s at a jewellery shop!
(The Riddler smashes the front store window)
BATMAN: He’s smashed the window!
(The burglar alarm goes off)
BATMAN: That’s the sound of the alarm!
The sad thing is that I’m not exaggerating. You start wondering if the Superfriends’ headquarters, the Hall of Justice, is really a care home. What’s more, the vocal acting matches their imbecility exactly. Stilted and one-note from beginning to end, it displays as much variation as the animation. I’m very fond of Apache Chief, who e-nun-ci-ates each and ev-ery syll-a-ble.
Hilariously, the characters all appear to treat each other as equals when it comes to their superpowers. The Scarecrow, who here is just a guy made of straw, is afforded as much respect as the super-genius android Brainiac. Toyman, whose special ability is that he gets on my nerves whenever he opens his mouth, is seen as a dangerous threat. A veritable platoon of hangers-on and wannabes continually parade up and down their respective headquarters, as if Superman couldn’t kill them faster than they could blink.
Which means that when Brainiac and Gorilla Grodd (a genius in his own right) go on missions, they have to suffer the Riddler, of all people, to come along with them. The Riddler’s superpower is basically to tell the good guys how to win, which makes his continued presence in the Legion of Doom all the more puzzling. Meanwhile, Superman has a public parade thrown in his honour, but has to endure Hawkman tagging along with him. For
Doctor Who fans, remember when the Doctor was knighted by Queen Victoria? Imagine that Peri was with him instead of Rose. It’s rather like that.
And, finally, the animation really is no better. Yes, this was the age of cheap, cheap labour. The overriding rule, at all times was that only the bare minimum of characters on screen should ever move, and as little as possible. I’ve mentioned above the lacklustre fights, but the animation adds an extra-special touch; imagine that the combatants are on the verge of falling asleep and you’re pretty near it. Facial expressions change as often as total eclipses take place. Characters move as stiffly as Cybermen. It’s enough to make grown men weep.
But the fun doesn’t stop there, oh no. It really shouldn’t be that hard to steer clear of continuity mistakes, but the animators trample over every rule going. In one scene Superman’s hair goes blond. Characters appear in two places at once. Characters are shown to fly when they’ve never previously been able to. Black Manta’s helmet is so flat he could only fit into it if Gorilla Grodd had sat on his head. The concept of visual scale is flung down and danced upon.
It’s kind of like Claudio Fragasso had drawn it, actually. And that sentence alone should tell you whether you’ll enjoy this series or not. I had a whale of time.
At least I did when the Toyman bloody shut up.
Thanks to the miracle of YouTube, let me show you a little of the horror...
Oh, just in case you were wondering – surprisingly, the Joker does not put in an appearance. I’d like to think it’s because he has his pride, and my respect for him has consequently gone up.